We Deliver Smiles!!!

Our twelve “everyday” cookies are $6.29/dozen (Snickerdoodle, Chocolate Chip, M&M, Oatmeal, Oatmeal Raisin, Kiss, Peanut Butter, Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip, Chocolate Chocolate Chip, Sugar and Oatmeal Chocolate Chip with Whole Wheat flour and  Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Balls.

We also offer a variety of other baked goods:
(please pre-order)


$4.29/1/2 dozen
$9.99/ 8×8 pan
$12.59  1/4 sheet
$24.99  1/2 sheet
$48.99  Full Sheet
Homemade brownies that are to die for!  Chocolate Chip, Nut, Peanut Butter, M&M, Peanut Butter Chip, Butterscotch or Frosted

Pudding Cakes…..
$12.99 – $27.99
A rich, creamy combination of cream cheese, pudding & whipped topping!!!!

Sweet Rolls
$4.99/tin of 9
$3.99/ half-dozen
We believe these rolls are the sweetest around and we think you’ll agree with us!

Diabetic Cookies…diabetic cookie stick vase
Great tasting cookies without all of the sugar!  Choose from Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal, Oatmeal Raisin, Sugar, Peanut Butter! (Made with Whey Low).

Now offering a vase of diabetic cookies on a stick, 1 dozen for $25.99 plus tax.

Gluten Free Cookies:


(pre-order ) Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Choc.Chip w/ raisin, Peanut Butter, or Brownies! Also Monkee cookies are Gluten Free!

8×8   $16.99
1/4 sheet   $20.99
1/2 sheet    $38.99
Topping:  choose from raspberry, strawberry or cherry
8×8  $3.99       1/4 sheet  $4.99       1/2 sheet  $7.99
A wonderfully smooth and rich cake that will keep you coming back for more…and more…and more…..24 hour Pre-order notice only

Mini-Cheesecake cups…$8.19/dozen Topping is $0.75 per dozen.
The perfect size…not to big, not to small….but you can’t eat just one…
(Must order in dozen quantities at least 24 hours in advance).


8×8  $13.99
1/4 sheet  $19.99
1/2 sheet  $32.99
Full sheet    $56.99
Delightfully moist!
Choose from yellow, chocolate, carrot or raspberry.  Vanilla, chocolate, raspberry or cream cheese frosting.  Personalized as you desire!!!  Pre-order at least 24 hours ahead.

$7.59/dozen                                                                                                                      Cupcakes
$5.29/ ½ dozen
$1.29 each
Baked with love to enhance the sweet flavor.
*must order in dozen quantities*

Chocolate, yellow, carrot, raspberry available.   White, chocolate, raspberry or cream cheese frosting (white frosting can be tinted).

Big Cupcake  $16.99  Great as a “smash cake”!!!

Tear Apart Cupcakes Cakes (total amount of dozen’s plus $8 – $10 depending on design/decoration)

Gender Reveal Cupcakes $8.29 /dozen

Cup Cake Tier:   $20.00 Rental
$5.00 back when returned
$75.00 if not returned

Miniature Cupcakes  $5.99/dozen

All the above flavors but just big enough to pop in your mouth…..

Miniature Cookies $5.99/dozen
Order ahead and we can make your favorite cookies in perfect bite-size pieces!

Frosted cut-outs
$6.99 – $12.99/dozen
We bake them fresh every Wednesday or you can call ahead and we will do them any day you want them.

We also have “Seasonal” Cut-outs for every holiday as well as our “Sports” line (i.e. basketball, soccer, football, hockey, volleyball, baseball). We can customize a cookie for any occasion…Baby Showers, Bridal Showers, Thank You, Birthdays…choose from over 100 shapes.  If we don’t have the shape you need, bring us the cutter and we will do it for you!!!!!

Homemade Pies.…$11.99-$12.99
Delicious anytime of the year….Choose from apple, red raspberry, cherry,  pumpkin, blueberry and lemon meringue.
Enjoy our Cream Pies:  Chocolate Cream, Banana Cream, Coconut Cream, Peanut Butter or Key Lime…$11.99

Cookie trays.….$8.29 – $67.99
Whether you need a tray for a meeting, party, sympathy or whatever occasion, we can put a tray together for you!

1 dozen regular assorted  $8.29
2 dozen regular assorted  $14.79
3 dozen regular assorted  $21.99
4 dozen regular assorted  $29.99
5 dozen regular assorted  $36.49
6 dozen regular assorted  $42.59
7 dozen regular assorted  $48.69
8 dozen regular assorted  $54.79
9 dozen regular assorted  $61.99
10 dozen regular assorted $67.99

We can customize your tray with regular cookies, cut-outs and brownies….call us for details!!!!

Our homemade Whole Wheat or Italian Bread, Muffins, Gluten-Free Cookies and Brownies are available by pre-order only!!

Now Availalbe!!!  Our “Frozen Cookie Dough” !  Bake our delicious cookies at home.  Eat them “hot” out of the oven!!   $8.79/2 lb tub (24-32 cookies)!!  Call us about Fundraising!!


Case-Nic Cookies

439 Main Street
Medina, NY 14103

Monday-Friday 10 a.m. - 5 p.m.
Saturday: 9:00 a.m. - 1:00 p.m.
Closed Sundays

Special Days Calendar

September  2017
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30


Copyright © 2017. All Rights Reserved.